×

Registration

Please provide the following information

ALREADY HAVE AN ACCOUNT ? login

Where do you teach?

Tell us what you teach

CTRL-F: Find the Facts is an online verification skills module designed to help students evaluate digital information and determine what to trust.




Create your account

×

TEACHER LOGIN

×

RESET PASSWORD

×

Add A New Class

Class details


Offline-Assignments Case Studies

Posted: July 01, 2020

Is a photoshopped photo always misinformation?

Why an altered photo of Green Party leader Elizabeth May's mug became news

Key Concepts:

 Manipulated content
Offline-Assignments

Last week, Green Party leader Elizabeth May faced media questions about a cup swap in a photo on the Green Party website.

 

A photo posted of her holding a disposable (but compostable) cup was replaced with the same image, altered in Photoshop. In the new version, the cup is reusable plastic, sports the Green Party logo, and contains a reusable straw.

 

Numerous news outlets in Canada and abroad reported on the story, including the National Post.

 

Some pointed out a contradiction in having a party devoted to environmental issues artificially adding a reusable cup to its leader’s hand.

 

Elizabeth May expressed surprise that the image had been altered, and said the following in a statement:

“My personal daily practice is to avoid single use plastic items 100% of the time. I never drink from plastic water bottles. I always carry my own reusable coffee cup. I carry my own bamboo utensils. I walk the talk every day. I hope that despite this misstep by well-meaning party staff (who hoped to brand the image with our logo), people can believe that in the original photo there is nothing I would have hidden.”

  1. Share the article “Elizabeth May was holding a single-use cup before photo was altered to a reusable one,” that ran in the National Post on Sept. 24 with students.
  2. Optional: Review the animated video CIVIX Explains: Information Pollution.
  3. Have a class discussion of the issues raised by this event. Guiding questions:
  • Why do you think this story is newsworthy?
  • How might this photo be considered an example of misinformation?
  • What are the reasons people might be upset about this photo being altered?
  • Do you think it is ethical to change a photo this way? Why or why not?

Thank you

Your tools are ready for you,

Thank you for registering. We hope you find the materials on this site valuable and engaging. If you have questions or feedback, please contact us at hello@ctrl-f.ca